Overview:
The Shs2.15 billion ($521,302.36) was withdrawn in 62 transactions between 2017 and 2019. The court ordered DTB to refund the money to Global Wire Industries, with the bank entitled to recover it from Sabharwal.
Diamond Trust Bank (DTB) has been ordered to refund Shs2.15 billion to Global Wire Industries after the High Court found that the lender negligently processed 62 unauthorised withdrawals from the company’s account over a two-year period.
The Commercial Division of the High Court also held company director Rajiv Kumar Sabharwal personally liable for the money, finding that he had orchestrated the transactions using forged signatures and company resolutions to gain control of the account.
In a November 13 judgment, Justice Stephen Mubiru ruled that DTB breached the account’s operating mandate, which required two directors to sign cheques before money could be withdrawn.
The judge said the bank had also accepted a forged company resolution purporting to give Sabharwal sole authority over the account, despite the existing joint-signature arrangement.
The Shs2.15 billion ($521,302.36) was withdrawn in 62 transactions between 2017 and 2019. The court ordered DTB to refund the money to Global Wire Industries, with the bank entitled to recover it from Sabharwal.
Justice Mubiru further awarded the company Shs25 million in general damages against DTB.
Forged signatures, disputed resolutions
The dispute arose from a business partnership between Rajendra Kumar Jayantilal Thakkar and Sabharwal, who incorporated Global Wire Industries in April 2017 to manufacture binding wire for Uganda’s construction industry.
Each held a 50 per cent stake in the company, with Thakkar responsible for supplying machinery and raw materials from India, while Sabharwal was tasked with managing the local operations.
Both directors were signatories to the company’s DTB account, meaning neither could independently authorise withdrawals.
However, court records show that Sabharwal allegedly used a series of forged documents to alter the company’s banking arrangements and gain control of its finances.
Among the disputed documents was a November 7, 2017 resolution purportedly authorising the use of a property title as security for a DTB letter of credit.
Another resolution, dated September 3, 2018, purported to grant Sabharwal sole signing authority over accounts held with Exim Bank.
A separate resolution dated March 2, 2019 sought to give him similar powers over the DTB account. Justice Mubiru found that DTB accepted the document despite the requirement for both directors to authorise transactions.
Thakkar told court that he discovered the irregularities after returning to Uganda in 2019 and began investigating the company’s financial records.
He engaged accountant Denis Legamoi to examine bank statements covering October 2017 to April 4, 2019.
In a report dated April 26, Legamoi identified withdrawals amounting to Shs2.15 billion, which he attributed to Sabharwal.
Bank, URSB ignored warnings
Thakkar subsequently reported the matter to police and, on April 9, 2019, formally notified DTB that cheques drawn on the company’s account carried a signature he had not authorised.
Six days later, he wrote to the Uganda Registration Services Bureau (URSB), raising concerns about forged company resolutions and asking the agency to stop registering further documents presented by Sabharwal.
However, court records show that a resolution dated April 20, 2019 was subsequently used to remove Thakkar as a director.
URSB also registered additional documents on April 25 and 26, despite having received his complaint.
The agency maintained that it had compared the disputed signatures with those in its records and dismissed the complaint after its assessment.
Justice Mubiru, however, found that the warning should have prompted further verification before the agency accepted additional company documents.
He held that URSB’s actions contributed to Thakkar’s exclusion from the company’s management.
Thakkar filed a civil suit on June 6, 2019, seeking recovery of the money and damages arising from his removal.
His exclusion from the board had complicated efforts to obtain a company resolution authorising legal action. The court eventually allowed him to pursue the recovery proceedings on behalf of the company while also seeking compensation for his personal loss.
Sabharwal’s criminal conviction
The financial dispute also resulted in criminal proceedings against Sabharwal.
In January 2020, he appeared before the Anti-Corruption Division of the High Court facing charges of embezzlement, forgery and uttering false documents.
He initially denied the charges and was granted bail but later changed his plea to guilty after three prosecution witnesses had testified.
On November 25, 2021, the court sentenced him to four years in prison and ordered him to pay Thakkar Shs556 million in compensation.
Sabharwal challenged the conviction and sentence before the Court of Appeal, which dismissed his appeal in October 2022. He subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court.
In August 2023, Supreme Court Justice Faith Mwondha granted him bail pending determination of the appeal.
His lawyers, led by Caleb Alaka, cited a serious heart condition and a history of gastrointestinal bleeding in seeking his release.
Prosecutor Stanley Baine opposed the application, arguing that Sabharwal could abscond and questioning whether the medical evidence demonstrated that prison authorities could not manage his condition.
Justice Mwondha granted him bail on payment of Shs10 million in cash and ordered him to report to the court registrar every 14 days.
Court rejects bank’s defence
In the commercial dispute, DTB denied liability, arguing that it had acted within its mandate and that Thakkar had approved the disputed payments when contacted.
Sabharwal, meanwhile, maintained that Thakkar had signed company documents in advance to enable him to operate the business during Thakkar’s absence.
But Justice Mubiru relied on handwriting evidence, Thakkar’s denial of the signatures and Sabharwal’s guilty plea in determining that the withdrawals were unauthorised.
The judge said the transactions were irregular whether they were processed using cheques bearing forged signatures or Sabharwal’s signature alone under the disputed banking mandate.
He rejected the bank’s attempt to shift responsibility to its customer, holding that DTB had failed to demonstrate that the company had substantially contributed to the forgery or that the bank itself had exercised due care.
The court consequently held DTB liable for the full Shs2.15 billion, alongside Shs25 million in general damages payable to Global Wire Industries.
Justice Mubiru also awarded Thakkar Shs150 million against Sabharwal and Shs10 million against URSB.
In arriving at the compensation payable by Sabharwal, the judge took into account the earlier Shs556 million compensation order made in the criminal proceedings.
The court further nullified the forged company resolutions and directed URSB to reinstate Thakkar as a director of Global Wire Industries.
The Shs2.15 billion refund attracts annual interest of 10 per cent, while the general damages awards attract 15 per cent interest, all running from November 13 until payment in full.
